How I voted for the 2016 All-Mountain West football team

Wyoming was well represented as the Mountain West released its all-conference football teams Tuesday afternoon.

Those who voted were the 12 head coaches in the league, and selected media — including myself.

Craig Bohl

Craig Bohl

Third-year coach Craig Bohl was the Coach of the Year. Redshirt freshman linebacker Logan Wilson of Casper was the Freshman of the Year. Four players made the first team: junior running back Brian Hill, senior tight end Jacob Hollister, senior offensive lineman Chase Roullier and sophomore free safety Andrew Wingard — all of whom I had on my first-team ballot. I also voted for Bohl and Wilson in their respective awards.

Here’s the link to see the entire 2016 All-MW football honorees:

http://www.themwc.com/news/mountain-west-announces-2016-football-all-conference-teams-and-individual-honors-11-28-2016

 

There was some controversy, at least among the fans.

Josh Allen

Josh Allen

UW redshirt sophomore quarterback Josh Allen made the second team. Boise State sophomore quarterback Brett Rypien got the nod as the first-teamer. He’s the only player to be the first team quarterback in back-to-back years as a freshman and sophomore in league history. I had Allen as my first team quarterback, but if you look at the numbers, Rypien had the edge. You can’t go wrong with either one, and both were clearly the top two quarterbacks in the conference.

I was a little surprised that UW senior wide receiver Tanner Gentry didn’t make the first team. Colorado State junior Michael Gallup got the nod, along with Boise State senior Thomas Sperbeck, who was a no-brainer in terms of making the first team. Gentry and Gallup had similar numbers. Both caught 11 touchdown passes. Gallup had eight more catches (70 to 62) and 32 more yards (1,164 to 1,132). Gentry had a better yards-per-catch average (18.3 to 16.7).

Brian Hill

Brian Hill

Boise State fans were miffed that junior running back Jeremy McNichols didn’t make the first team. He certainly had the numbers to be there, and the way this league has been with running backs the last couple of years they should have at least three guys on the first team. But you also can make strong arguments that Hill and San Diego State senior Donnel Pumphrey (the MW Offensive Player of the Year) should be on there, too. Who do you leave off? Last year it was Hill.

Below is how I voted. Most of it lines up with the official results.

QUARTERBACK

Josh Allen – Wyoming

Brett Rypien – Boise State

RUNNING BACK

Donnel Pumphrey – San Diego State

Brian Hill – Wyoming

Jeremy McNichols – Boise State

James Butler – RB – Nevada

WIDE RECEIVER

Thomas Sperbeck – Boise State

Tanner Gentry – Wyoming

Michael Gallup – Colorado State

Jalen Robinette – Air Force

TIGHT END

Jacob Hollister – Wyoming

David Wells – San Diego State

OFFENSIVE LINE

Chase Roullier – Wyoming

Nico Siragusa – San Diego State

Daniel Brunskill – San Diego State

Mario Yakoo – OL – Boise State

Dylan Vail – Air Force

Fred Zerblis – Colorado State

Austin Corbett – Nevada

Jake Simonich – Utah State

Reno Henderson – New Mexico

Jake Bennett – Colorado State

DEFENSIVE LINE

Alex Barrett – San Diego State

Ricky Ali’ifua – Utah State

Sam McCaskill – Boise State

Kyle Kelley – DE – San Diego State

Nik D’Avanzo – New Mexico

Meffy Koloamatangi – Hawai’i

Ryan Watson – Air Force

Malik Reed – Nevada

LINEBACKER

Tau Lotulelei – UNLV

Dakota Cox – New Mexico

Tanner Vallejo – Boise State

Calvin Munson – San Diego State

Christian Tago – San Jose State

Kevin Davis – Colorado State

DEFENSIVE BACK

Weston Steelhammer – Air Force

Damontae Kazee – San Diego State

Jonathan Moxey – Boise State

Andrew Wingard – Wyoming

Brodie Hicks – Air Force

Malik Smith – San Diego State

Andre Chachere – San Jose State

Trayvon Henderson – Hawai’i

KICKER

John Baron II – San Diego State

Luke Strebel – Air Force

PUNTER

Hayden Hunt – Colorado State

Michael Carrizosa – San Jose State

RETURN SPECIALIST

Rashaad Penny – San Diego State

D.J. May – Wyoming

OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR

Donnel Pumphrey – San Diego State

DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR

Damontae Kazee – San Diego State

SPECIAL TEAMS PLAYER OF THE YEAR

Rashaad Penny -San Diego State

FRESHMAN OF THE YEAR

Logan Wilson – Wyoming

COACH OF THE YEAR

Craig Bohl – Wyoming